Language and Social Influence in Small Conversational Groups~
نویسنده
چکیده
University students, in groups of 3 or 4, discussed legal aspects of commercial surrogacy and aftenvards ranked the relative influence of each group member. As predicted, high-influence members spoke more words and had more successful turns during the conversation than low-influence members. The latter used a greater rate of intonation and intensifiers than the former. A closer examination of the results showed that turns were particularly important for high influence. Unexpectedly, tag questions and hedges did not result in low influence, probably due to the different usage of tag questions and to the nature of the conversation setting which, unlike one facing court witnesses, required tactful hedging in the exertion of influence. Language can mirror an existant social hierarchy. For example, the linguistic standards and preferences in schools, churches, and courts are those of society’s dominant groups (Mueller, 1973). The choice of pronouns, and of firstand last-name usages in conversations is governed, partly at least, by hierarchy (Brown & Ford, 1961; Brown & Gilman, 1960). Apart from this reflective role, language may also function as a means of social control (Fowler, Hodge, Kress & Trew, 1979; Lakoff, 1973). Presently, our concern is with the role of language in interpersonal influence. Social influence due to the use of language may be variously defined and studied. It may refer to induced changes in the behaviour (Blakar, 1979) or attitude (Jaspars, 1979) of message recipients. At the level of impression-formation, communicators who use different forms of language may be perceived by others as more or less powerful. Perceived powerfulness can be measured along such perceptual dimensions as dynamism, status, and competence. A comprehensive review (Bradac & Street, 1986) of the research in this tradition shows that most of the studies have cast the respondents in a listener or passive observer role rather than in the role of actual interaction participants. Taking a more interactive approach, we focus on small conversational groups to find out how the development of a social influence hierarchy among the group members may be related systematically to different forms of language used by group members during the conversation. For reasons to‘ be explained below, group members who occupy a low influence rank at the end of the conversation are expected to have used a 026 I -927XISh!03/020 I10 SU2.50,’O JOURNAL OF LANGUAGE AND SOCIAL PSYCHOLOGY ’C 19% hl. E. Droohe 6: S. 11. Ng
منابع مشابه
Ethnomethodology and Conversational Analysis
In a speech community, people utilize their communicative competence which they have acquired from their society as part of their distinctive sociolinguistic identity. They negotiate and share meanings, because they have commonsense knowledge about the world, and have universal practical reasoning. Their commonsense knowledge is embodied in their language. Thus, not only does social life depend...
متن کاملThe Relationship between Self-esteem and Conversational Dominance of Iranian EFL Learners’ Speaking
The crucial role of affective factors like anxiety, inhibition, motivation and self-esteem have long been of interest in the field of language learning due to their enormous association with the cognitive processes involved in performance in a second or foreign language. This study aimed at investigating the relationship between Iranian EFL learners’ self-esteem and conversational dominance in ...
متن کاملHand gestures and perceived influence in small group interaction.
A laboratory study was carried out to establish the relative importance of verbal and gestural behavior, as well as their interaction, for perceived social influence in more or less competitive small groups. Forty women (psychology students) participated in leaderless small group discussions of different sizes (four-member and eight-member): at the end, each member rated the perceived influence...
متن کاملMining Social Interaction Data in Virtual Worlds
Virtual worlds and massively multi-player online games are rich sources of information about large-scale teams and groups, offering the tantalizing possibility of harvesting data about group formation, social networks, and network evolution. However these environments lack many of the cues that facilitate natural language processing in other conversational settings and different types of social...
متن کاملOrganization of Gatekeeping and Mental Framework in the System of Representation and Hierarchical Relational Structures of the Modern Society
Critical discourse analysis as a type of social practice reveals how linguistic choices enable speakers to manipulate the realizations of agency and power in the representation of action.The present study examines the relationship between language and ideology and explores how such a relationship is represented in the analysis of spoken text and to show how declarative knowledge, beliefs, attit...
متن کامل